Stepping Back in Time

Today, after my BNI meeting, I asked for some help from our business coach about time management. It is an area I seem to struggle with lately. I want to know how to be most effective. He suggested I use a paper planner.
At first, I thought this may not be a good idea for me. But upon thinking about it further, I think he might be on to something. I can carry it EVERYWHERE, I can personalize it, I can same some money on my cell plan that already frustrates me, and I tend to be a list maker. Most of my lists are done on paper because I love the satisfaction of crossing off items.

What are you best time management tips?